Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Unsolved Mysteries:
Lost Colony of Roanoke
  • By Daniel
2
The Facts
  • Sir Walter Raleigh, and Englishman, went to Roanoke, an island near the coast of North Carolina,  with a group of English colonists. However, though they arrived in 1585, they went back in 1586. A second group arrived one year later, in 1587, led by John White. Virginia Dare, White’s granddaughter, was born that year in the new settlement. White later returned to England for supplies. His return was delayed three years by war with the Spanish. When he finally  arrived back, all the colonists had disappeared completely, a large fort wall constructed around the colony. The only trace was “CRO” and “CROATOAN” carved into the nearby trees. However, there was no Maltese cross beside these messages, which was a code arranged that meant they left for the area of native Croatoan tribe, and not in distress. Still, what became of the 113 colonists? Read on, and find out what some authorities believe.
3
Theories
  • Two main theories have been brought up to explain Roanoke’s disappearance. One ends with the majority of the colonists being slaughtered by natives, while the other states they blended with the native Indian tribes over time.


  • Aliens abducting the colonists was also offered as an explanation. However, there is no credible evidence to back this theory up.
4
Were the colonists killed by natives?
  • David Beers Quinn, a prominent historian, believes the colonists were murdered by natives. Originally, he thinks the colonists agreed to split up, with twenty-five men staying behind and the rest going to Chesapeake bay to try to settle there, and live with the Chesapeake Indians.
  • As for the twenty five men,  the theory says that after some time doubted White’s return, and moved to live with the Croatoan tribe. After all, they were all men, isolated and alone. Also, they were running out of supplies. Just in case John White arrived, they carved the messages in the trees.


5
What happened to the others?
  • Quinn’s theory is that a very powerful tribe called the Powhatan, named for it’s leader, killed them all. The cause was their Chieftain thought the English would overthrow his tribe, and he believed this because of prophecies by his priests. As more of the English started settling near his land, he became more and more worried, and he sent his warriors to eliminate the lost colonists and their Chesapeake hosts, and what he thought was threat to his power. He then later said the Chesapeake were unfriendly, leading English settlers away from signs of the slaughter.
6
Supporting Evidence
  • Englishmen of the Virginia Company went inland to try to find a spot to settle. They found many odd things, such as a mysterious clearing five miles around. They also saw large clouds of smoke which they though was from a native fire. Even stranger was farmland and a plot of strawberry bushes. Throughout, they saw no natives at all. The smoke could have been Powhatan’s warriors burning down evidence of the massacre, and the land former agriculture of the Chesapeake.
7
Supporting evidence con.
  • Powhatan later confessed to being present at the massacre of the colonists, but he had also become named sub-King of the region through cooperating with King James, so his priests were blamed for the slaughter.
  • There was a report of four men living with as native tribe near the Roanoke area, and the report said they had been left by Walter Raleigh, and had escaped the slaughter, and were smelting copper for the tribe. However, there is no actual proof that these were really four of the lost colonists.
8
Did the colonists blend with the Natives?
  • Stephen B. Weeks believed that the colonists soon moved after White left. However, they did not move to Croatoan island, which was barren and sandy. He thinks they moved to a different place that was inhabited by the Croatoan Indian tribe, the peninsula of Dasamonguepeuc. As time passed, Weeks believes they became integrated with the natives, and eventually became one.
9
Clues
  • One report by a colonist says that he spotted a native boy in the area of the colonists with “hair of a perfect yellow and… white skin.”
  • There were also rumors of some of the colonists within fifty miles of the Jamestown fort. There had been crosses and letters found carved into the trees.
  • John Smith was told by a native leader who lived near Roanoke that he had seen men like Smith.


10
More Clues
  • William Strachey, a member of the Virginia Company, reported stone, multi-floor houses built in English fashion, however being built by the natives.
  • Stephen B. Weeks found that Croatoan natives had similar speech patterns to the lost Colonists. (i.e.: father was pronounced fayther and wit was used instead of knowledge)
  • There are many more clues that help support this theory.
11
My Opinion
  • Personally, I believe that they were killed by Powhatan’s warriors. I also think that they split up after some time after John White left, and were killed shortly after going to the Croatoans. Basically, I believe David Beers Quinn, whose theory I mentioned first.  Though there is mounds of reports that would imply English influence on the Croatoan tribe, it’s Powhatan’s confessions that seals the deal. I don’t think a powerful leader like him would lie and say he did something that would get him in trouble with the English. However, you may have a different belief, and you could be right. After all, it is still and unsolved mystery.
12
A Special Thanks To:
  • Schouweiler, Tom. The Lost Colony of Roanoke San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1991
  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roanoke_Island
  • http://usparks.about.com/cs/parkhistory/a/virginiadare.htm
  • http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/280/5363/564
  • Clip Art
  • Power Point






13
Click on the detective to return to the Unsolved Mystery Homepage